Best Yarn Stores in Appleton, Wisconsin

Casting On is a welcoming yarn store that strives to be a resource for knitters of all skill levels. While some reviews mention occasional inconsistencies in pricing and a slightly cluttered atmosphere, the store is overwhelmingly praised for its knowledgeable and friendly staff, particularly Sara, who is known for her patience and willingness to help customers find the perfect yarn and patterns. The store is LGBTQ+ friendly and has implemented safety protocols during the pandemic. Several customers have noted the helpfulness of the community, with one reviewer mentioning that they were assisted with a pattern and yarn selection. The store also offers classes and workshops, and has a strong online presence. Some reviewers have noted that the store is a bit small and can get crowded, but the overall experience is consistently positive. The store’s commitment to creating a safe and inclusive environment for all customers is a key selling point.