Best Yarn Stores in New Preston, Connecticut

Stars Hollow Yarns is currently on pause, with the owner, Lisa, stepping back from retail to focus on a planned Maker Space. Previously, the store was known for its carefully curated selection of yarn, focusing on natural fibers, organic yarns, and non-superwash options, and for its welcoming atmosphere. Reviews consistently highlight the friendly and knowledgeable staff, the shop’s "little pocket of magic," and the strong sense of community built over seven years. The store’s values included sustainability and ethical sourcing. Despite the temporary closure, Lisa is actively seeking community input for this new venture, aiming to create a space dedicated to creativity, connection, and care. Some reviews mention a slightly cliquey atmosphere, but overwhelmingly the experience is positive, with customers praising the helpfulness and enthusiasm of the staff. There have been some comments about pricing being a little high, but the quality and selection are generally considered worth it.